The Fearless Influencer Podcast
Mark Harbert is on a quest to empower online entrepreneurs across the globe to break free from the daily grind and live life fearlessly on their own terms. Amidst the buzz and chatter of online marketing advice, whether you're a newbie or a seasoned marketer, Mark has an uncanny ability to sift through the noise and deliver the real deal—what's genuinely effective right now. He's all about demystifying the intricate and making it digestible, so you can focus on crafting a winning strategy. The Fearless Influencer Podcast aims to equip you with an unshakeable entrepreneurial mindset while laying out a tactical roadmap for achieving peak performance in online marketing. With years of experience dating back to 2009, Mark has been enlightening the online marketing community through his blog, social media, premium courses, and one-on-one consulting. If you're eager to elevate your game and become a fearless influencer in your niche, hit that subscribe button and tune in to the Fearless Influencer Podcast today.
The Fearless Influencer Podcast
#64: Why Your Emails Land in Spam and How to Get Seen | Adrian Savage
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Love The Podcast? Click Here To Send Us A Text! I Would Love Your Feedback.
Why are your emails going to spam, or just not getting seen? I sat down with Adrian Savage, who has made it his core mission to help people get better engagement on their email lists, and this one matters because it's not just about building a list anymore. It's about having an engaged list, and Adrian breaks down what Google, Microsoft and Yahoo are looking at when they decide where your email lands.
If you're spending money to grow your list and a big chunk of your emails never get seen, you're setting money on fire. Adrian told me about a business spending 30 grand a month on ads while 50% of their emails weren't being seen by anyone.
In this episode you'll learn:
- Why your sender reputation matters more today than the platform you send from
- Adrian's "point of no return": for a typical list, he's seeing 14 to 17 days
- The worst engagement signal (your email left sitting in spam) and the best ones (being rescued from spam, and replies)
- Why Adrian doesn't think you should ignore open rates, and why the trend matters most
- Why "delivered" doesn't mean it landed in the inbox
- His visibility index: what percentage of your new leads open at least one email
- Whether the promotions tab is really as bad as everybody says
- Why tricks to game the inbox can get you blocked
- How to use AI for your emails and still sound like you
- Adrian's favorite re-engagement subject line
Check out Adrian's Visibility Center: https://visibilitycenter.com
Watch the full interview on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ad2uPeVNpH8
Read the blog post: https://markharbert.com/emails-going-to-spam/
More from me: https://markharbert.com
Know somebody who's building an email list and wondering why nobody's opening? Send them this episode.
Mark Harbert: All right. Well, welcome everybody to the Fearless Influencer podcast. Exciting episode we've got here for you today, and, uh, we've been working to get this one worked out for a couple months, but I'm super excited to have on with me good guy Adrian Savage.
And Adrian, great to have you. I know, um, for if you guys have been listening to me any length of time, you know I am probably one of the most anal guys when it comes to email marketing and why you need to focus on email. Uh, but not just building a list, but having an engaged list.
And honestly, uh, Adrian is one of those guys who has made it his core mission to help people get better engagement on their email lists, and I've been using some of his stuff for years. Um, he's a great guy. Adrian, great to have you on, man.
Adrian Savage: Thanks, Mark. It's great to be here.
Mark Harbert: Yeah. So I guess let- let's dive into it a little bit. First, let's hear your story a little bit.
I know everybody's got a story. You've been doing this for a while. Um- Oh, yeah ... and honestly, when I really started paying attention to deliverability, it was actually through you and your platform, you know?
Um, 'cause I, I knew it was important, but as it became more and more important and you, you know, some of the stuff that you guys, uh, did with EmailSmart was, like, really kind of opened my eyes deeper to why, you know, you've gotta have this engagement, you know, and why- Sure ... it's so important. So anyway, let's hear your story, man. How'd you get into it?
Adrian Savage: So I mean, I've been a geek since I was seven years old. Um, my dad brought home an Apple II computer. You old enough to remember them?
Mark Harbert: I, man, I was around in the Commodore 64 days, man.
Adrian Savage: Ah, there you go. So, so this was probably just before that. Yeah. Um, and yeah, my dad brought it home.
He was about to throw it out the window, so seven-year-old Adrian starts reading the manual and teaching Dad how to use the computer. So I've been kind of, I guess, been a geek for life. Um, but I did the usual thing. Went to school, studied, got into corporate life, that kind of thing.
I didn't escape until 2011, so that's 15 years ago now. Um, and when I escaped, I wasn't sure what I was gonna do at that point, because my ex-wife had just moved to the other end of the UK with my kids, and I knew that if I stayed in my corporate job, I wouldn't see my kids. Yeah. So I quit my job, not quite knowing what I was gonna do, which was obviously scary as hell.
Um, and I started joining mastermind groups, and the mastermind groups were all talking about the same thing, about automating your marketing and email marketing and stuff like that. Um, and I wasn't the best marketer in the room, but I was certainly the best geek in the room, and all the other folks, every time all this techy stuff was mentioned, they looked like rabbits stuck in the headlamps. So I was there going, "Hey, I can do this." So that's how I discovered Infusionsoft. That's how I became, um, I became the first Infusionsoft certified consultant to get 100% in the exam, um, back in 2012.
Um, and very quickly when I started working with email marketers, I found that some of them were having problems getting their emails seen even back then. Um, and it wasn't until about 2015, 2016, that I really niched down completely into what back then I called email deliverability. I've got a new name for it now, which we'll cover I'm sure.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: Um, but even back in 2012, 2013, I was getting clients and it was like, "Why is all these emails going to spam," and stuff like that. Mm-hmm. And as time went on, I started to dig into this a bit more because I lost a couple of clients when I couldn't solve their problem, and I don't like not being able to solve people's problems for them. Yeah.
Um, so I made it my business to work out, well, why the heck are these emails not landing in the inbox? And obviously back in 2012, the rules were very different then to what- Yes ... they are now because... And I still tell people now, you can't market like it's 2012 anymore.
Right. Um, and back then it was easy. You built the biggest list you could, and then you just kept mailing the heck out of them until they either buy, die, or unsubscribe, right?
Mark Harbert: Right. That was it.
Adrian Savage: And if only it was that easy now. Um, so yeah, and the, the big reason that people struggled back then was because the only game in town was, well, what's the reputation of the IP address sending the emails out? Um, and some platforms had good reputations, some platforms had bad reputations, and it was simple as that. Um, but then things started to shift because then they brought in all these techy things like email authentication that we've all grown to know and love now.
You know, we can't send an email out now unless it's got a DKIM signature on it, and that signature tells us that we, you know, that that's come from our domain and we're, we, we trust the platform that's been s- that's been sending it through that domain. So nowadays, the reputation of the sending platform doesn't really matter anymore, although everyone still talks about that and they say, "Hey, ActiveCampaign's got bad deliverability. MailChimp's got good deliverability," which is actually a load of BS, to be- Yeah ... honest. Yeah.
Um, but back in those days, that was, that was the truth, and if you're on a platform and you're being sent from a, from a bad IP address, you were kind of stuck. Um, so we got to about 2015, 2016, and back in those days Infusionsoft weren't doing the good job they do now on- Yeah ... reputation management. They had a lot of IP addresses that had bad reputations.
Um, and also there's always the, you know, there's, there's always gonna be this challenge that some email filters, some email platforms hate marketers- Yeah and they always will. So I worked out how to actually reroute the emails that Infusionsoft sent out so it looked like it was a transactional email and not a marketing email.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: And suddenly at that point, and that's when I started working with some of the big boys in the email world- Yeah ... because they realized that I could get them a few extra points on their open rates.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: And if you're mailing out 150,000 people at a time and you can get 2% extra on your o- open rate-
Mark Harbert: That's huge ...
Adrian Savage: and the conversion rate stays the same, that's another few tens of thousand dollars in the bank.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: So that w- that was the start of my real specialism in- Yeah ... what I now call inbox visibility.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: You know, how can we get as many people as possible to see the emails that you send out? Because let's face it, if you've got the same email list or if you're spending the same amount on ads or whatever you're doing, if you can get more people to see the same stuff you're sending out, you're gonna get more conversions and make more money out of it. Mm-hmm. So that, that is the approach that I've taken ever since, and it's looking at the numbers and getting the best possible value out of an email list.
Yeah. And a lot of people don't understand that. You know, I've worked with people spending 20, $30,000 a month on Facebook ads-
Mark Harbert: Yeah ...
Adrian Savage: and they don't r- they don't measure how effective those emails are at being seen when they follow up.
Mark Harbert: Right.
Adrian Savage: And, you know, I had one prospect that didn't become a client because, how do I say this politely? They didn't understand.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: They didn't understand that 50% of the emails they sent out weren't being seen by anyone. Yeah. So out of the 30, 30 grand a month they were spending on ads, they were, they were literally setting $15,000 a month on fire And yet they never did anything about it. I think they increased their ad spend instead.
Mark Harbert: Yeah. That's
Adrian Savage: insane. So I had to wi- I had to wish them well and move on because- Yeah ... you know, there's sometimes you can lead the horse to water, but if the horse wants to die of thirst, then there's nothing you can do, right?
Mark Harbert: Right. Yeah. Um- It's so true, you know?
I mean, I, and like, I, I used to, you know, like I've, I've been doing this now for almost 20 years and, I mean, it was drilled into my head back in 2007, 2008, you know, the list, the list, nothing but the list, like the list. Like, that's the thing, and I still believe that today. But the truth is it has changed and, you know, a lot of people still treat their email list like a one-way promo tool.
Adrian Savage: Yeah.
Mark Harbert: You know? And I, I have just shifted... See, I, I watch people too, and you can talk to this and, and we- we can start getting into some of the engagement things and the metrics and what look at. But I've really adopted the idea that I don't look at my email list as just a one-way communication.
It's a two-way. Exactly. And so I treat it more like a social network than I do, you know, like people are like, "We wanna juice the algorithm on Facebook." So they go and they comment, and they do all these other things. It's like you can do that with email and get way more bang for your buck than you would on social, 'cause that little juicing you do might last you 24 hours, 48 hours, whereas you do it with an email, man, you're gonna get way more out of it and inbox deliverability just from that engagement.
Yeah. So let's talk about engagement a little bit. I know, you know, we've talked about how things have changed, you know, in the last 15 years, whatever. Let's talk about that, you know, the change.
Adrian Savage: Yeah. I mean, it's, it's interesting because- I guess email started to really change once Google and Gmail in particular started to really grow. Because, you know, when we were getting started, it was the norm that you had to pay for your email, right? You had to go and pay, you know...
I mean, I remember CompuServe. That was, that was kind of the- Yeah ... start of it, wasn't it? And then you had AOL, and you had all these different platforms where you'd go pay for your email. And then suddenly out came Hotmail.
Um, and Hotmail kind of missed the boat a little bit. They didn't quite get it. But when Gmail came out, then suddenly everything exploded. Everyone had a free Gmail address.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: And the problem is if something suddenly becomes free, we become the product.
Mark Harbert: Mm.
Adrian Savage: And, you know, let's face it, Google did not do that to lose money. Yeah. Google did- Google released Gmail to make a ton of money, and they did it two ways.
The first way is they suddenly get insights into what's happening with, uh, everything in the world, because they can see everyone's emails that are coming and going. Um, and secondly of course, every single free Gmail account there is, they can make money by displaying ads.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: And that is... You know, that changed the world, maybe not quite overnight, but it started the big shift. Because obviously from Google's perspective, they still wanna make money out of email.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: And the way they're gonna make money is if someone opens the email, they display an ad, and someone clicks on the link in that ad, and Google makes money.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: So suddenly if we're sending out emails to our audience, it's not just do we send something that our audience wants to see, but it's like, well, are we gonna send something that Google's gonna like?
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: And what is it that makes Google ultimately like us or not? Well, it's what our open rate looks like. If we send out 100,000 emails and we get a 5% open rate, then that's only like 5,000 people opening emails- Yeah ... and 5,000 people to, for Google to make money out of. If you send 100,000 people and you get a 50% open rate- Mm ... then Google can suddenly make money out of 10 times more people.
They can make money out of 50,000. Yeah. So Google are obviously gonna favor you, the better your open rate is.
Mm. Um, and there's two parts to it. Okay, some of it is money, but some of it is because they do also wanna give their users a good experience.
Mark Harbert: Sure.
Adrian Savage: And, you know, if you're on my email list and I'm mailing you every couple of days, and you ignore my emails, Google are gonna very quickly pick up on that and they'll say, "Hey, Mark isn't opening Adrian's emails. Why should we show them to him?"
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: And if you ignore me for long enough, then the emails I send you are gonna go to spam. Now, the thing is, if John down the road is opening my emails, the ones I send to him won't go to spam.
Mark Harbert: Mm.
Adrian Savage: So it's no longer just one big spam filter. But what Google are doing, and what everyone else is doing now, is they're tailoring the way they process the emails depending on each person's behavior, whether... What they read and what they don't read.
Mark Harbert: Mm.
Adrian Savage: So on the one hand- It's still really important that you gotta look after your reputation and send things the way that Google want. But also, you've gotta recognize that you're not just dealing with one spam filter at Google anymore. If you've got a list of 50,000 people on Google, you're dealing with 50,000 spam filters.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: And that makes it a bit more complicated. But the principle is still the same, because what we wanna do is we wanna send out emails that have got the highest possible chance of being opened. Because if we're doing that, then that's what Google are gonna like because we've got a high open rate.
Mark Harbert: Hmm.
Adrian Savage: And this is why I often say every single email you send is either gonna help or it's gonna hinder your reputation. And obviously, if you get a ton of emails that get opened, that helps you. But if a ton of emails get ignored, that's gonna hurt you, and that's why the engagement management matters so much.
There's absolutely no point sending emails to people that are ignoring you, because this is when I often talk about Einstein's definition of insanity. Do you know that one?
Mark Harbert: Oh, yeah. Doing the same thing over and over again. Yeah. Expecting a different result, yeah.
Adrian Savage: Yeah, exactly. You know, if I've mailed you for the past month and you haven't opened a single darn email I've sent you, why on earth are you gonna open the next one?
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: You know, that, that's like trying to get water to flow uphill or something crazy like that. People, you know... Yes, occasionally you can wake people back up and re-engage them, but most of the time if someone has ignored you for a few weeks or longer, you've probably lost them forever. Um, quick digression on that because there's a, um, a metric that I've created that I don't know that anyone else uses.
Um, and I call it the point of no return. Mm. So what I'll do is I'll look at someone's email history, um, their sending history for, say, six months, and we'll say, "Okay, how many days can you go and someone will still come back and open your email?"
Mark Harbert: Hmm.
Adrian Savage: So if you go one or two days, the chance of someone opening your next email, if they, you know, if they haven't opened your email for a couple of days, the chance of them opening one after that are pretty good. But supposing you get to 10 days since they last opened your email, what are the chances? You get to 20 days, 30 days. And the scary thing is, three or four years ago, that point of no return was around 30 days.
Mark Harbert: Hmm.
Adrian Savage: But here we are in 2026 And for a typical business to consumer email list, and it does vary depending on the audience, the age, and lots of other things. But for a typical list, I am seeing somewhere between 14 and 17 days as the point of no return. If someone hasn't opened your email in the last 17 days-
Mark Harbert: Mm ...
Adrian Savage: the chances are they never, ever will again.
Mark Harbert: Mm.
Adrian Savage: And that's really scary because it- Yeah ... doesn't give you too long to keep people's interest before they go away. You gotta work out how to keep them engaged. And to the folks that are sending one email a month as a newsletter, like it was 2012- Yeah ... it's like you, you've probably lost half your audience by the time you- Yeah ... send the next email out.
I know. So thing- things have changed massively. But the golden rule still has to be follow the rules that Google set, because Google is the great big, you know, behemoth in the email world.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: And we've gotta make sure that we follow their rules, and Microsoft and Yahoo are up there as well. And the good news is, most of the rules they set are similar.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: But we've gotta follow the rules and we've gotta send, we've gotta send emails out, and we've gotta behave in a way that Google's gonna approve, 'cause if not, they can, they can slam us in Google jail faster than you can say deliverability.
Mark Harbert: Yeah. Yeah. It's, uh, it's...
And, you know, when you really get down to it and, um, I, I wanna say something like the billions and billions of emails that are sent every day, it's like 50% of those emails are actual spam emails. Like-
Adrian Savage: Yeah.
Mark Harbert: Yeah ... it's a massive amount. So you, when you understand, like, I mean, you've been around a long time, Adrian. I, I remember, was it maybe 10 years ago when they introduced the tabs, you know, the promo tab. Yeah, yeah.
And the marketers were flipping out. You know, it was like, "Google's dictatorship" and like they're freaking out. It's like I saw the writing on the wall. Like, no, I mean, people are getting flooded with email.
They're trying to give you the tools to, like, help you have, make a better experience and, and ultimately that's, that's really, um, what it comes down to. But I, I do wanna go even deeper here on engagement because this is so important, is the signals that they're looking for. You know, because I think when we dive down into the signals of what, what, you know, helps determine engagement, that's where we can devise a good strategy to get people- Yeah
engaged and how we can do that. Okay. So let's talk about that.
Adrian Savage: Well, I'm actually gonna start on the flip side of that. I'm gonna say what are the signs of non-engagement? Because this is what we've gotta protect against more than anything else, okay?
Because, and this is the thing that people don't understand. I know something about inbox visibility, how to get your emails seen. But when someone joins my email list and I send them that first email, even I who am doing everything as you should, the chances are maybe 50/50 whether that email that I send out lands in the inbox or the spam folder.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: So first and foremost, I've got to educate people right from the get-go. If they sign up to my email list, I need them to go and check their spam folder straight away, because the worst possible sign of disengagement is your email landing in spam-
Mark Harbert: Yeah ...
Adrian Savage: and then they leave it there.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: If they do that, then the chances are that every single email you send in the future is also gonna end up in spam. And it doesn't even matter if you've got a good reputation, unfortunately. Yeah.
You know, Google and Microsoft and Yahoo are suspicious as heck of any kind of change. So if you start mailing someone out the blue and they haven't emailed you first-
Mark Harbert: Yeah ...
Adrian Savage: then they're gonna say, "Hmm, this might not be what they want. Let's put it in the spam folder just to be safe."
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: So you have to train your audience right from the word go. If they fill out a sign-up form on your website or they opt in for something, you've gotta tell them there and there, "Go and check the spam folder." Yeah. But that, even that isn't enough.
You gotta say, "Not just check the spam folder, but drag it out of the spam folder into the inbox, mark it as safe." Yeah. Because if you don't do that and it just gets left there-
Mark Harbert: Yeah ...
Adrian Savage: then you're essentially telling Google, "I don't wanna hear from this person again."
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: So that's the biggest thing is, you know, how can we change people's behavior so that when that first email goes out, they're gonna go and find it and hunt it- Yeah and actually open the thing and mark it as safe. Yeah. So that's probably the most important thing.
But equally, if, if your email just lands in the inbox and they ignore it or they just delete it without reading it or they archive it without reading it, any of those things, we don't want that to happen- Yeah because that is gonna hurt our reputation. Because what Google are doing here is every single person that you're sending an email to, they're gonna be using that as crowdsourced reputation data. What do these 20,000 people think of Adrian?
Yeah. And if 18,000 of those people are ignoring me every time, then- Yeah I'm not gonna get very far.
Yeah. So that's kind of, that's the, that's the, the, the bad side of it. But then let's look at what's the good side.
Obviously, the good side we talked about is if you rescue an email from spam, that's one of the best engagement signals you can get, 'cause it means that- Yeah someone has actually made the effort- Yeah ... to find the email- Yeah ... and say, "Hey, I wanna keep this. I wanna hear from this person."
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: Um, a close second to that, um, I think it's something that you, you mentioned earlier when we were talking, is get people to reply.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: You know, that, that takes real effort. It's, you know, anyone can get someone to open an email or even click a link, but to get someone to reply and actually send you something- Yeah ... takes a bit of effort. Um, so if someone does that, then that's one of the best, best- Signals,
Mark Harbert: yeah ...
Adrian Savage: signals that you've got to say, "Hey, this person is clearly engaged and is actually responding to the emails that I've sent out." So an open is really important. Um, you know, sorry, a, a reply is really important.
Um, opening emails, clicking emails, they all matter as well. Getting someone to actually put your email address into their safe senders list or their address book or whatever, that matters as well, because again, that's giving Google a signal that you wanna hear from someone.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: Um, but it is, it's working out well. How can we demonstrate that people wanna receive our emails, and how can we demonstrate that they are actually reading them? 'Cause the crazy thing is, all that we can see as marketers are we can see an open signal, which is about 50% reliable if we're lucky. Yeah.
Um, you know, on the one hand, we've got Apple with their mail privacy protection that makes emails look like they've been opened when they haven't. Yeah. And then on the other, we've still got some email clients that actually block the tracking.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: So in other cases, it'll look like someone hasn't opened your email when they have.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: So, you know, you've got all these marketing experts saying you have got to ignore email opens.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: And I am actually gonna challenge that because we do actually- Good, I'm
Mark Harbert: glad, 'cause I, I believe we should challenge that too. And-
Adrian Savage: Yeah, absolutely ...
Mark Harbert: I think it's people trying to overinflate their importance sometimes. Yeah.
Adrian Savage: Yeah. You know, anyone who says ignore opens, then, you know, I'll be respectful and say they've probably got a reason to say that. Mm-hmm. But there is a huge level of importance understanding what your open figures look like, and, you know, one, one of the reasons that it becomes important is if you look at the point of no return for clicks-
Mark Harbert: Yeah
Adrian Savage: it's somewhere between 100 and 120, 150 days.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: So I've got evidence that people will not click for three or four months and then come back and click something.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: So if you're excluding people from your email list after they, say, haven't clicked for 60 days or something like that, then you're excluding a lot of people that could still come back. Yeah. So we have got to look at opens as one signal of engagement.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: But at the same time, if someone- has opened every single email that you've sent in months, but they haven't clicked anything for, like, a year, that suggests they probably aren't really engaging with you. Because you've gotta get, you know... I mean, okay, some people don't put call to actions in emails, but I'm a bit old-fashioned. I believe that every single email you send should either get someone to reply or click.
Mark Harbert: Yeah,
Adrian Savage: yeah. There's gotta be some kind of call to action. I mean, I, I, I know that some high-ticket people or business to business, they might say pick up the phone. Yeah.
And obviously you can't track phone calls with emails. Yeah. But I think that's, that's in the minority these days. Yeah.
Most of the time we want clicks and we want, we want replies. But that open rate still matters- Yeah ... because we wanna, we wanna send emails to people that open in the last 30 days. You know, that's, that's the, that's the guideline that I still stick to.
It used to be 90, but 30 days, it's still more than the point of no return, but I see a small number of people still do occasionally open if they've ignored you for the past 20-odd days. It does depend on the audience. But the thing that matters most about the open rate isn't the rate itself.
Mark Harbert: Mm.
Adrian Savage: Although what I would say is that if you're getting open rates of less than about 50%-
Mark Harbert: Mm ...
Adrian Savage: it suggests that you're not managing your engagement properly.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: Because I would say that Apple, Apple's mail privacy protection probably about doubles the open rate that you're really getting. So if you're get- You know, I remember going back to, you know, 2015, 2017, a good open rate was 20 to 25%.
Mark Harbert: Mm. Yeah.
Adrian Savage: These days, with everything being inflated the way it is, I'd say a good open rate is 50 to 60%, which means in reality maybe you got 25 to 30% of people really opening.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: But that rate matters, um, because unless there's some big algorithm change and Google suddenly start measuring differently or they start blocking things or Apple changes mail privacy, then that open rate needs to stay about the same. Mm. So if you're getting a 50 to 60% open rate week in, week, week out- Yeah ... that's a good signal that your engagement is staying pretty solid.
Mm. If that suddenly drops off, you need to worry because something's gone wrong. Now, it might be there's been an algorithm change-
Mark Harbert: Yeah ...
Adrian Savage: but more often than not, it's because maybe, you know, people have lost interest in you. Or if the rate goes up, then yeah, that tells you something's actually going okay. But the trend really matters with this stuff.
Yeah. You know, you can't troubleshoot emails from open indicators. It's like the number of people where they'll say, "This person hasn't opened an email, therefore something's wrong."
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: Or someone gets in touch and say, "I need you to troubleshoot this email that isn't getting delivered."
Mark Harbert: Mm.
Adrian Savage: And that's one of the toughest things in the world because one of the kind of bits of headline news that people don't always know is that email is not designed to be a reliable, guaranteed communication medium.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: It's always been best effort right back from the '70s. You know, they've got these, they call it simple, Simple Mail Transport Protocol, SMTP. That's the language that mail servers speak. And the problem you've got- Is that just because something gets accepted for delivery doesn't mean it's gonna make it into the inbox.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: So we might say that the email's been delivered, and this is why the, the... This is why I don't use the term deliverability anymore, because it's- Yeah ... confusing as anything.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: You know, let's say you're using, you know, whether it's, you know, GoHighLevel, Mailchimp, ActiveCampaign, it doesn't matter what you use, they all work the same way. They're gonna try and send one email after another, and supposing you're using Gmail, they'll go knocking on Gmail's door and say, "Hey, I've got an email for Mark. Are you gonna accept it, yes or no?"
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: Gmail will either say no, in which case that's a bounce. We all know how they wor- they work. Um, if the email bounces, then you know that it pretty much hasn't got through.
But just because it's been accepted and it says it's been delivered, then there's all the other stuff we've gotta go through. You know, um, Google will check the authentication, they're gonna look at the content, they're gonna look at the reputation.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: And then they might put it into the spam folder, they might put it into the inbox, they might put it into pr- promotions. Um- So
Mark Harbert: it got delivered, but it, not where you necessarily wanted it.
Adrian Savage: Yeah, exactly. It's been, it's been delivered to the mail server, so great, you know, um, GoHighLevel's done their job. They've delivered the email that you asked them to send.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: But, you know, you, you cannot trust any platform that says, "I will tell you what's happened to that email."
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: Because I haven't given anyone permission to snoop on my mailbox.
Mark Harbert: Mm.
Adrian Savage: And the only way someone's gonna know whether go- something goes into spam, inbox, or promotions is if I tell them.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: You know, there's, there's, there's software out there that will say, "We will tell you where your emails are going," but the only reason they do that is 'cause they buy what's known as panel data. Mm. And what that is, is they, they've got maybe 100,000 people to turn over access to their mailboxes so they can see what happens to all the emails that land in them.
Mark Harbert: Mm.
Adrian Savage: But that's such a small representative sample-
Mark Harbert: Yeah ...
Adrian Savage: that unless you've got a big part of that panel in your audience-
Mark Harbert: Yeah ...
Adrian Savage: it doesn't tell you enough. Yeah. So you can't trust it.
You know- Yeah ... the only people that know where, where an email has been delivered are the people that receive it and the mailbox provider itself, be that Google, Microsoft, Yahoo- Yeah ... or whatever. And other than that, we are guessing, and it's difficult. It's very difficult.
Mark Harbert: Yeah. Yeah, and, um, uh, I think one thing I wanted to mention on the open rate, which I think is a key also, like even though w- like, let's just say we, we don't get, um, an indicator back that there was an open. It doesn't mean it wasn't opened. Maybe there- Okay ... maybe the Gmail sees that it was opened, they have all that data, but our little tracking pixel may not have said, "Hey, it was opened."
Yeah. So in reality, you could even have a higher potential open rate than what you're even getting back. I mean, that's-
Adrian Savage: Yeah, that's good. And this, this is the thing. On the one hand, you know, the tracking pixel gets blocked, or there's Apple that load it anyway, whether it's been- Yeah ... whether the email's been opened or not.
So we can never be 100%. We've gotta- Yeah ... look at other indicators, which is why I wanna get people to click, I wanna get people- Yeah ... to reply. But it is a nightmare, but at the same time, the trend really matters.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: But as, you know, and, and if the, if the open tracking is the best we've got to go on, then that's what we've gotta use, right? Yeah. Because- Yeah ... the alternative is just to go back to marketing like it was 2012 again.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: And just mail everybody.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: And if you do that, then, well, I've worked with the clients that tried that.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: And all I will say is it doesn't end well.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: Um, because- Obviously, this is probably a good segue into the next thing I want to talk about, actually, because it's like, well, how can you tell how good your reputation really is?
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: Um, now, in the good old days, this time last year, Google had a really good report in their free Postmaster tools that told you what your domain reputation was.
Mark Harbert: Mm.
Adrian Savage: But Google, for reasons best known to themselves, they've decided to get rid of that report.
Mark Harbert: Mm.
Adrian Savage: So we can no longer go to Google and say, "Hey, what do you think of me? What do you think of my domain that I'm sending these emails from?" Yeah. And that's really difficult and, you know, for... as, as a, as a email deliverability inbox visibility guy, that was one of my best sales tactics because I say, "Oh, look- Yeah ... you've got a low Google reputation.
You need me- Yeah ... to fix that for you." Um, can't do that anymore. Mm.
But obviously you don't normally need to be a rocket scientist to know when you are in some kind of trouble- Yeah ... with Google, because you'll find your open rates start to go down. Yeah. But worse than that, and this is why I go back to people that are doing paid ads, is the best way you can check your reputation as a sender is to see what happens to your new leads.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: Because we've talked about how, you know, we, we've got lots of different spam filters for every single user out there. Mm. But if I sign up for someone's email list today, and I've never had received an email from them before- Yeah ... Google can't look at my repu- look, like, Google can't look at my behavior- Yeah
to work out what to do with it. So the only thing they can do is say, "Well, what do we think of this person as a sender? What is their reputation?"
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: And the better the reputation is, the more likely it is to land in the inbox. Yeah. The worse it is, the more likely it is to go to spam. And if you're getting a lot of your new lead emails getting opened, then you can infer from that that you've got a good reputation.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: And, you know, one of the metrics that I measure, and again, this is something that not many people look at, and I don't understand why, but I call it the visibility index. What percentage of new leads are opening at least one email from you?
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: And if you've got a good reputation, and there's a little bit of kind of alignment needed here, you've gotta have a good offer, you've gotta have a good lead magnet, you've gotta have a good ad. They've all gotta match each other because, you know, if, if they sign up for some kind of widget and the email that you send them is about sprockets, they're gonna ignore it.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: So you've gotta make sure that the email all lines up. But as long as they line up and you've got a good reputation, you should be getting 80, 85, 90% of your new leads opening at least one email- Yeah from you in the first couple of weeks.
Mark Harbert: I was just gonna say, and this is, this is very important, I'm glad you hit on it So I know, I know how my people think, and they're gonna be like, "Well, how do I make sure that they're, they're gonna get my email or find it or whatever?" First off, it's all about the offer. Like- Yeah ... you need to have an offer that is really irresistible in front of the right audience, where they want what you are giving them so bad that they're gonna go search for it 'cause they really wanna make sure they get it. Yeah.
That right there, you know, you really gotta think through that first and make sure that that's clear, 'cause that'll certainly help. Because if it's just kind of a, "Okay, eh, it'd be nice to have that, okay." Yeah. And then, but they're kinda like not super motivated to go check, that's gonna be part of it too.
Adrian Savage: Yeah. I've got a little story actually that, that, that backs that up because, um, I've been working with a client over in, based in Europe for the last three or four months now. Um, and when I started working with them, they had, they had hurt their reputation to the point where less than 25% of their new leads were seeing something.
Mark Harbert: Hmm.
Adrian Savage: So effectively they were, they were burning one third to three... Sorry, they were burning two thirds to three quarters- Hmm ... of their monthly ad spend, and they were literally setting it on fire because- Hmm 25% maybe were seeing the emails, 75% weren't. Now, I worked with them, and they got to the point where they went from 25% of their new leads opening to 75% of their new leads o- opening.
So that was like a 3X improvement on their return on ad spend. Hmm. But then the agency they were working with very clearly didn't do the best job with the ads. Mm.
The relevancy started to slip. The audience- Yeah ... wasn't the right fit for the offer. So even though their technical deliverability is still really good- Mm ... they've gone from 75% opening to 65%- Mm ... because it's not such a good match.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: So you gotta make sure that the- it's the right ad to the right audience with the right offer, 'cause if any of those things go off, it doesn't matter how good your technical deliverability is, it all matters together.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: So that was quite a learning experience for me. But when you're looking at that new lead engagement rate, what I call the visibility index, particularly if you're spending a ton of money on ads- Yeah ... it really matters because, you know- Definitely ... you don't, you don't wanna waste money emailing people that aren't gonna see the emails.
Mark Harbert: Right.
Adrian Savage: Yeah. And if your reputation's bad enough, that is still what's gonna happen.
Mark Harbert: Yeah. Yeah, that's some really good insights, there's no doubt about that. That's, uh, that's a key. I think too, you know, like, and, and as we're talking, I'm thinking, like, little strategy here and there.
Like, how do you, like, really focus? I mean, the big thing is you have your main offer, which you could have somebody opt into. They go back, it's just super irresistible. They wanna find it.
But the cool thing is, once they find that email, you could have something in there that says, "Hey, by the way, I got something else for you too. You know, um, if you reply back to this email, I'll send it to you." You know, whatever.
Something that really just immediately is like a one-two punch, you know what I mean? Get them to want to open the email and find it, click whatever it is, and then reply back to you. You got a win right there.
Adrian Savage: Yeah. You know? The, the more you can get people to engage, particularly from the get-go- Yeah
the more it matters. Because if, if someone joins your list and you can't get them to engage right at the start when they're most- been most motivated-
Mark Harbert: Yeah ...
Adrian Savage: then you don't stand much chance a few weeks down the line.
Mark Harbert: Yeah. What, uh... So from, like, let, let's talk too here, like- From a new lead click-through rate, what are you kind of searching for? Like, obviously that's a...
We talked about open rates, a big one, 80, 90% if you can get that, obviously. Yeah. What about a click-through rate?
Adrian Savage: So this is where it gets interesting, because obviously the, the click rate is gonna be dependent very much on the offer, the copy- Yeah ... things like that. Um, but I can share the best... 'Cause one of the, obviously, one of the advantages of having software that I'm gonna talk about that actually reports on this stuff, so I can measure all these key metrics like point of no return, what the visibility index is, something called the smart score that tells you how well you're managing the engagement on your existing list. So we have got thousands and thousands of different marketers where they have measured all this.
Mark Harbert: Hmm.
Adrian Savage: And, you know, we don't learn from it, we don't, we don't put it through AI models and stuff like that because, you know, that's, you know, we don't wanna make money from people's data. But what we do do is we maintain a league table. Yeah. So we know what the good, the bad, and the ugly looks like.
We know there's some people out there that are getting a 10% new lead engagement rate. Hmm. We know there's other people that are getting a 92, 93% new lead engagement rate, and they use the same platform.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: You know, this is the thing that really, really winds me up sometimes, is people will blame it on their platform, even in 2026, when it's the sender's reputation that matters now.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: But they will blame it on the platform, but I've seen people, doesn't matter whether they're using, you know, going back to Keap or Infusionsoft or GoHighLevel or even Mailchimp or whatever it is.
Mark Harbert: ClickFunnels. They, you know,
Adrian Savage: they're-
Mark Harbert: Yeah. Yeah.
Adrian Savage: Yeah, absolutely. Um, it doesn't matter what platform they're using, then you will get people with really good results and people with really lousy results, and the only difference is the people with the good results are following the rules and doing what I recommend.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: And if they're doing that, they're gonna get the great results. Yeah. But from a click, so from a click perspective, um, so Evan, who's my co-founder of EmailSmart, one of his clients is Martha Beck.
Mark Harbert: Hmm.
Adrian Savage: Um, obviously a massive email list.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: She doesn't have a problem with g- with getting leads and traffic and stuff like that. You know, it's great to be a, it's great to be a well-known celebrity, right? So because she has got a well-known brand with a well-known offer and working with Evan, she's got every single thing right with her inbox visibility, she is getting between 50 and 60% click rate of new leads. Mm.
So that doesn't mean it's a click rate from one email blast. Yeah. But it's... So suppose she gets 1,000 new leads in 30 days.
Mark Harbert: Mm.
Adrian Savage: We can say that around 600 of those new leads will have clicked on at least one email that she sent out. Yeah. So that's where the 60% new lead click rate comes from.
Okay. But that is possible. I see most people getting 10 to 15%.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: Now, sometimes the reason they're getting 10 to 15% is because only 30 or 40% of their new leads are opening something.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: So when that's the case, then obviously the first thing to do is to fix all the, all the, all the issues you've got with your inbox visibility so you can get up to 70, 80, 90% of people seeing your emails, opening them, and then they're gonna click more.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: But then once you are up to 80 or 90% opens, if you're only getting 20, 30% clicks, then you can probably improve your offer, improve your relevancy-
Mark Harbert: Yeah
Adrian Savage: um, or just get better at making the call to action more prominent.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: But yeah, you can get 40, 50, 60% of new leads clicking something.
Mark Harbert: I gotta get my benchmark up. I was just looking at my little score and I'm like, "Oop, I got 21% click-through rate on new leads." I wanna work
Adrian Savage: on that. Oh, there you go. So, what do they say in Mission Impossible? "Your mission, should you choose to accept it."
Mark Harbert: No, it's great. Like, um, but I, I really wanna point out here, and this is very important, like, um, I've generated a ton of leads over the years, like, uh, well over 200,000. Like, but when you really get down to it, my active list today is very tiny. Mm-hmm.
And, um, you know, example, recently, uh, competed in a big affiliate launch, um, uh, with Russell Brunson and some other people, and, uh, I was in the top 10. I got seventh place out of this co- out of this contest- Wow ... with people that had six, seven, 800,000 people on their email list. And here I am with this tiny list of about 8,000 people, and I'm right up there running. And now from the opt-in, they had two contests.
There was an opt-in contest and the sales. I was actually, like, 17th or 18th on the opt-in contest, but I was right up there in the sales. You see what I mean? Because I've, I've nurtured this list so much- Yeah.
Yeah ... and really gotten that. And so I really, I'm saying this 'cause I wanna make the point of, that we can get too wrapped up in the vanity metrics of thinking, "Oh, that'd be so awesome to have a list of a half a million people." Really?
Like- Yeah ... I mean, really, I mean, that sounds sexy, but the truth is, if nobody's buying and nobody's seeing it, what the heck does it matter? Yeah.
You're just gonna be spending a lot of money sending email, you know? Yeah. And you're not getting it back, and that's the key.
Adrian Savage: Yeah. Yeah. And that's why engagement matters.
It doesn't matter if you... You know, I've worked with people, they've got an email list of 250,000.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: But if only 30,000 of those have, have opened something in the last 30 days-
Mark Harbert: Yeah ...
Adrian Savage: then that means the other 220,000 unfortunately have gotta be put, you know, not necessarily entirely in the trash.
Mark Harbert: Mm-hmm.
Adrian Savage: But I think the number of times I've been approached by people saying, "I've got this email list, it's 100,000. I've not emailed them for three years." Mm. And they expect that I can do miracles. And, you know, the bottom line now is that your, your permission to mail, and I don't mean the rules or, you know, I don't mean in, in Europe we've got GDPR, you know, you've got- Yeah
California's rules, you've got Canada's rules. Yeah. You know, I don't, I don't give two hoots about the rules.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: Because what really matters is- What is someone subconsciously giving you permission to do?
Mark Harbert: Yeah. '
Adrian Savage: Cause when they sign up to your email list, they are giving you permission to message them there and then, for sure.
Mark Harbert: Yeah, yeah.
Adrian Savage: And as long as you continue to engage with them, then that permission will not lapse.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: But if you ignore them for a couple of months and then, say, mail them out of the blue, they're gonna say, "Adrian who?" Hit the spam button, you're out of there. Um- It's the amount
Mark Harbert: of time, man. I- Yeah ... I've been on people's lists and I know I'm on their list.
I just got an email a couple days ago. They're like, "Oh, where have I been for three years?" Uh, you know? And it's like, "Oh, by the way, uh, I've got something I'm launching soon."
Adrian Savage: Yeah, yeah.
Mark Harbert: Come on, man. And, and the
Adrian Savage: thing is- Like, crazy ... that, you know, that, that trust has been, that trust and permission to-
Mark Harbert: Yeah
Adrian Savage: keep in touch has been eroded by all that time they've not been in, in, in v- in touch. Yeah. I mean, you know, if you're a r- really strong personal brand that someone who knows you well, then maybe you'll get away with it. Or maybe if you're, if you're Pepsi or something, you can send an email out and everyone rec- the brand recognition is good enough.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: But for a typical, typical brand mailing an audience that hasn't got that much loyalty- Yeah ... then, you know, an email list that hasn't been mailed for three months is pretty stale, and you might get some of it back. But if it's a year, then you can mainly kiss that list goodbye. And, and here's the crazy thing. This, it's 2026, people are still buying email lists.
They're still sending out cold emails. Yeah. Um, and, and Goo- Google have actually got to the point now where if they find someone using a cold email warmup service, they will ban them.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: Um, but people still try it. But at the end of the day, if you don't have permission to send someone an email, then you're taking a big risk. And yeah, there's, there's, you know, there are cold email experts out there, and they, they get very good results. But the reason they do it, on the whole, is because they send such a small number of emails every day-
Mark Harbert: Yeah ...
Adrian Savage: it stays under Google's radar. You know, if you're sending 20, 30, 40, 50 emails a day to people that you're just doing cold outreach to- Yeah you'll probably get away with it, unless you're getting a ton of complaints back. Um, but, you know, the days when you could just spam people with 1,000 emails at a time-
Mark Harbert: Yeah ...
Adrian Savage: it ju- it just, you know, there's probably a few people that get away with it for a while, but I mean, I remember back in 2018, Google had something called TensorFlow, and that was their AI tool, because Google were using AI back before it was a thing-
Mark Harbert: Yeah
Adrian Savage: um, to learn what the bad actors were doing. Yeah. And if they were doing that back in 2018, can you imagine what Google's AI is doing now with spam detection and stuff like that and, and- Yeah ... cold outreach?
It's like, you know, it takes a lot to stay ahead, and you, you can't game Google. I mean- Yeah ... that's, I'm, I'm gonna jump on my soapbox for a second on that one, Mark. So just, you know- Yeah ... pl- please forgive me for this, but what, what do you think of emails landing in the promo tab?
Mark Harbert: Uh, I, I don't personally think it's the end of the world. I mean, honestly, like I, I, I don't... I mean, it's like everybody talks bad about it, but the truth is, is I mean, I still check my Promos tab.
Yeah. You know what I mean? I, I, I don't think it's really that big of a deal.
I mean, of course pe- you're probably gonna, if you land in the Inbox, that's gonna be, you know, m- uh, probably much better. But I mean, I, I don't know. I don't really think the Promo tab is as bad as everybody makes it out to be.
Adrian Savage: Yeah. And I can, I haven't got the exact figures to hand, but I can give you two different things that will kind of back that up. Yeah. So the first one is a few years back, um, one of the big email kind of stats companies published something about the readership level of how likely emails were to get read, whether they land in the Inbox or Promotions.
Um, and I'm, I'm making these numbers up, but they're kind of close to what it was, but I think the chances of an email getting read in the Inbox was something like 20%. Mm. Um, if it landed in the Updates tab, it was something like a 27% chance of being read. Mm.
So actually, the Updates tab was better than the Inbox. And I think the Promotions tab was only, like, 19% or something. It was only just lower than the, than the Inbox.
Um, so you know, all this panic that people have about, "Oh my God, my email's landing in Promotions." Yeah. Like you says, you check your Promotions tab. If you wanna be promoted to, you're gonna check your Promotions tab.
Mark Harbert: Right.
Adrian Savage: And, and there, there was a big glitch. I can't remember if it was the start of this year or the start of last year, but for three or four days, Google didn't route emails to Promotions tab. Mm. Everything landed in the Inbox for a few days before they had a glitch.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: And in that time, the unsubscribe rate on promotional emails went through the roof.
Mark Harbert: Wow.
Adrian Savage: Because suddenly- That's interesting ... people are seeing all this stuff and it's like, "Hey, I don't wanna be sold to right now."
Mark Harbert: Right.
Adrian Savage: At least if it's in the promo tab and it's a promotion, then people have the chance as to when they wanna go and look at it.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: And then they're gonna engage. So actually-
Mark Harbert: When you, yeah, when you think about it, if they go to the promos tab, they're in a mindset to be promoted to.
Adrian Savage: Yeah.
Mark Harbert: Yeah. That's exactly it. That's, that's a good, that's a great
Adrian Savage: point. No, and I think the problem is, you know, when you, when you try and game the system and get out of promotions into the inbox, then it's like a wolf in sheep's clothing.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: You know? It's, it's not what it makes out to be.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: And then you open the email and, you know, and, and it's like in the past there's been this software that will get people out of promotions and things like that. And the way they do it is they just put all this kind of garbage boilerplate text at the bottom of each email, and they've got s- you know, Google got smart to that. So what the latest software does is it puts a different version of the boilerplate text at the bottom of every email. Yeah.
Which is great, but that's something called hash busting. Yeah. And the spammers have been using it for years and years to try and get around spam detection. Um-
Mark Harbert: It's black hat.
Adrian Savage: Yeah, it is. Yeah,
Mark Harbert: that again is black hat. Yeah. You know,
Adrian Savage: it's
Mark Harbert: not gonna get you busted eventually.
Adrian Savage: Exactly. Well, well, well, Marcel, who's kind of very high up in email at Yahoo, he's actually gone on record to say that when Yahoo find people using that software, they will block them.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: Because it's, like you say, it's, it's black hat. It's not what the good guys do.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: You know, it's much easier and much better and much simpler in the long run just to do the simple things. Yeah. Be a good, be a good email citizen- Yeah ... and don't try and game the system because, you know, you and I have both been around long enough.
Yeah. We know there ain't no such thing as a silver bullet.
Mark Harbert: No, there isn't. It's why, it's kind of funny, like, uh, I do have... My domain reputation is very good, uh, 'cause I'm, I am very engaged on it. Um, I've had this domain for, gosh, 15 years now.
But, um, I had this email deliverability guy, um, who I met in a Facebook group, and he went and opted into my list, and it went straight to his inbox tab. And he wrote me, and he's like, "Well, I have nothing to pitch you now 'cause you landed directly in the..." He sent me the pitch, and I'm like, "Oh, cool. That's always great." So him and I actually became little buddies because he was like, he kind of realized that. Now, I'm not saying that's the case with every email, but, um, I just thought that was kind of funny.
Yeah. You know? So. But I- All right ...
I love that idea about the, I think the, the promotions tab is not the end of the world. And I love that about the updates, 'cause I've seen updates come in. I'm like, "Ooh, what's the update?" You know?
Adrian Savage: Yeah.
Mark Harbert: So.
Adrian Savage: And this is it. And, and if you're trying, if you try and conceal an update or conceal a promotion so it looks like an update, then yeah, pe- people don't like being, being tricked.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: So, you know, be, be open and honest with your stuff. Because if you are open, honest, and authentic, then in the long term that's what's gonna work. Sure, you can use various little tricks in the short term, and that might get you somewhere.
But I know enough people that use, you know, all the different softwares out there to try and do the clever stuff. Yeah. And they, you, you see their great testimonials because- Yeah ... the testimonials get complete- get collected after a week or two- Yeah ... when they've had the good results.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: But then go back and ask those same people what happened after three months.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: And a lot of them, they, you know, very quietly have to admit that maybe that software didn't do what they wanted in the long term.
Mark Harbert: Yeah. Yeah. It's too easy to get sucked into that stuff for short-term gain. Oh, yeah.
You know? Yeah. I think-
Adrian Savage: Absolutely ...
Mark Harbert: you know, I think in the online world we just gotta start getting much more of a long-term mindset. Yeah. Think about that and, um, you know, I think that that's, that's the key, so.
Adrian Savage: Yeah.
Mark Harbert: Well, I, I, I love it.
Adrian Savage: Yeah. 'Cause I think you've got it nailed, Marc. Because like you say, you've been doing this for a long time. You've got a small- Yeah ... but very well curated email list. You add value, you build the relationship.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: And, you know, you do not need a six-figure email list to be successful.
Mark Harbert: Mm.
Adrian Savage: You can, you can have a few thousand. Um, you know, it's like, what do they say in The Greatest Showman? "You don't need the world to love you, just a few good people." Right.
And email is just the same. As long as you- Yeah ... got the right people on your list and you're sending what they want, what they need- Yeah ... with the right value, that's, that's what's gonna work long term. And it doesn't matter what AI brings along.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: It's not gonna change that. It's just that, you know, the folks that can send stuff that don't clearly look like AI slop are gonna be the ones- Yeah ... that, that succeed. Because, you know, one of the things I often say to people is, to get good results with email, you actually do need to email as frequently as possible.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: But there's a couple of caveats with that. The first one is obviously, I've already said, every email you send either helps or hurts your reputation.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: If you're sending every day to all of what I, you know, I, I call the best folks on your list who've opened recently, they're the assets. Because we want our email to be a, a, an asset. Yeah.
You know, if you're mailing a ton of unengaged people, your email list is a liability. Yeah. So we wanna not mail the liabilities, we wanna mail the assets, and as long as you're mailing the assets as frequently as you can-
Mark Harbert: Yeah ...
Adrian Savage: that's gonna help. But AI has changed that a little bit, because if you mail your best assets with AI slop every single day, they're very quickly gonna get upset with that and they're gonna start unsubscribing or ignoring you. So it's like you've gotta do the work. There's...
You know, even with AI, it can help you. Yeah. You know, we all use AI, right?
Mark Harbert: Oh, yeah.
Adrian Savage: But you've gotta use it carefully, 'cause otherwise then it can, it can make- Well- It can help you make mistakes much more quickly.
Mark Harbert: It's, uh, you know, I use AI to help me write everything, but it, it'll go through five, six renditions before I'm ready for it. Yeah. You know what I mean? Totally.
Totally. And, uh, and then even when I do copy it and paste it into my template to send it, I'm still tweaking it, you know, doing the thing. So, you know, there's still... You can't just, "Hey, write me this email.
Boom, copy, paste, send." You know? You're, you're really playing a, a, a, you know, a game you're not gonna win in the long run. And, um, I, as much as I love AI, I am so in on AI on every level, uh, there always has to be... There's no replacement for you building the skills in your own-
Adrian Savage: Yeah ...
Mark Harbert: your own ability. Yeah. Like, and I think a lot of people are just forgetting that. They're always looking for the quick, easy button, and, um, it's like it's just doesn't exist.
Adrian Savage: Yeah.
Mark Harbert: You know?
Adrian Savage: Yeah. You know, I, I, I love AI because one of the things I sucked at was writing a message from scratch.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: So if I can get the AI to, to help me curate the ideas and- Yeah ... give me a starting point, I can improve other people's- Yeah ... stuff much better. Yeah. So, you know, I can improve AI, but if the AI gives me an email, I've probably changed well over half of it by the time it makes it- Yeah out the door.
Mark Harbert: Oh,
Adrian Savage: yeah. Because other- otherwise it just... Well, I still want it to sound like me. AI- Yeah ...
AI doesn't, doesn't sound like me. I mean, I'm, I'm hoping that every single person that sees this already knows this one, but I mean, let, let's see if you know it. What, what do you see as the biggest ever AI tell in any kind of stuff that comes out?
Mark Harbert: Oh, there's certain words. I mean, there are certain words that get used. There are certain...
I mean, you got the em dash, which is a biggie. That's
Adrian Savage: the one. Yeah. That's the one I was thinking of.
Mark Harbert: And, and, uh, if you don't tell AI, it'll emoji you to death.
Adrian Savage: Yeah. You know? Yeah. I mean, it does that too.
AI's always, "It's this, not this," and, you know- Yeah there's just various things. Yeah. But the em dash is my, is my real soapbox one- Yeah ... because it's like, okay, just show me for a second, where on the keyboard is the freaking em dash?
Mark Harbert: Right. I had, uh... What's funny, I saw somebody online the other day, they're like, "You know, it's not fair.
Everybody sees the em dash and, uh, they think it's AI. I've been using em dashes ever before AI." And I'm like, "Well, you're screwed now, so- Yeah ...
Adrian Savage: you
Mark Harbert: might as
Adrian Savage: well stop using them." I know people like that. You know, pro- proper editors and, you know- Yeah ... copy editors and, you know, g- Yeah ... good old, good old-fashioned people that understand the- Yeah ... the English language. It's like, yeah, they've kind of, they knew when to use it, and now they're screwed.
Yeah. But mo- most of the rest of us kind of heathens who didn't understand it, then we just- ... we just know something to avoid, right?
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: But, but yeah, there's, there's too m- there's too many ways that it looks- Yeah ... like AI, and- Yeah, it, we, our, our mission is to- Yeah send good quality stuff out that the AI helps us with, but it's gotta be, you know, pe- people still wanna feel the emotional connection. Yeah.
Yeah. And AI can't yet do emotion.
Mark Harbert: Yeah. And it's, it's, you know, there's really the, um, you know, you really have to, like, take it serious. I mean, every email you send out is all your reputation. You know, everything, you have to think of it that way.
Like, every email I send, like, I always, I know it's a reflection of me, and I'm building, uh, a, a relationship with my audience. And I, I make no qualm, my audience knows I use AI, but I still want it to be like me, still want it to sound like me. Yeah. I don't want junk out there.
Yeah. It still has to... It's helped me cut, you know, and be, you know, 100 times more productive, but in the end it's still gotta be me, you know? Yeah.
Totally. That's, that's what people are bought into. So- Yeah.
Yeah ... this has been awesome, Adrian. I mean, there's so many killer tips in here that we could, you know, I'm sure we could talk for hours on this stuff. Um, final question, and, you know, do you have a favorite subject line to help get some re-engagement?
Adrian Savage: Yep. Please help with the old fashioned smiley on it, the colon, the dash, the bracket
Mark Harbert: Oh, okay. Please help. That- Oh, nice. That's a good one ...
Adrian Savage: that, that one still gets... You know, because nor- normally I would use that for a survey.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: But that's still, as long as you don't overuse it- Yeah ... that one still works. That's the one... I haven't sent it in my list for a while, so maybe I'll do that. You know, the best one for that is if you've got a product and, you know, and you, you, you'll know this one.
Yeah. It's like I'm gonna send this... I'm gonna, I'm gonna create this product. Yeah.
But how do I know which of the three or four titles is best? Yeah. So you send something out saying, "Please help." Say, "Hey, I'm just... You know, tell me, tell me what product you want me to create next.
Is it you want-" Yeah ... "1, 2, 3, or 4?" And just, you know, reply 1, 2, 3, or 4, or click the links. Um, and that, you know, sometimes I've had like 7, 8, 9, 10% click rate on that when- Yeah.
Mark Harbert: Wow ...
Adrian Savage: and, and, and obviously then that tells you what, what, what name to give the product that you've already created.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: So yeah. Ple- please help is my favorite one.
Mark Harbert: Yeah. Back in the day, I mean, my audience knows me pretty good, but, um, there's one I do like to use, but it's very spe- I... Maybe once every two or three years if I have something that I'm trying to promote. Uh, one I found gets major opening, but it could piss people off, is, "Congratulations, you just made a commission." I usually only use that one though when I wanna make a point.
Like, imagine seeing subject lines like that every single morning, you know? Uh, so you got, you have to be very careful, but, um, you know, it, uh, you just gotta test, too, what your audience- Yeah ... uh, likes. But-
Adrian Savage: Yeah. It, it depends. You know, you've, uh...
So if you're gonna use a little, you know, a little bit edgy stuff or humorous stuff, you've gotta make sure that you've got that- Yeah ... that kind of audience to get away with it. Yeah. If you, you've got a very kind of straight, straight- Yeah ... straight-laced audience, then you- Yeah ... wouldn't get away with it.
Yeah. If it's a bunch of marketers who wanna, who wanna earn a few bucks of commission- Yeah ... you're gonna get away with that every time- Yeah, yeah ... as long as it's like the same. You wouldn't do it every week, but- Yeah ... every, every six months or, you know, every now and then- Yeah ... works perfectly
Mark Harbert: Yeah. So Adrian, where can people find out? Now I know you, you've got a great tool. I use it e- every day.
I mean, you know, it's, uh, you've put together an awesome tool. Where can people kinda get some, uh, information on that? And I know you've got, uh, um, kind of a tool you put together, people can get some evaluations. Yeah.
Adrian Savage: So be- best place to find all the, all the good stuff now is, uh, the new software I've created. It's called Visibility Center. Um, and the beauty with that is there's enough of it that works no matter what email platform you use. Yeah. 'Cause in the past I could only work with certain platforms if they gave me the right data through their API and this kinda thing.
Um, but Visibility Center is gonna look at things like authentication, so it's gonna make sure your SPF, your DKIM, your DMARC is set up. Now we can do that for anybody, doesn't matter what platform- Yeah you're using. Um, it's got a content analyzer in there.
It'll actually, um, you know, one of, one of the things that Evan, my co-founder, has done is he has, over the years he has given people reviews on their email content to say, "If you change this, you are less likely to get filtered." Yeah. So we've actually taken that 10 years worth of wisdom and put that into a content analyzer where people put an email in and it will tell them whether it's likely to get filtered or not and, and why and what to change. So those two bits work for anything. We've got re- we've got Reputation Monitor that will actually connect up to Google Postmaster Tools- Mm ... and tell you if you're in compliance with Google or not.
Yeah. So all these things work, you know, you could, you could use the most obscure email platform in the world and it, and Visibility Center will still work. Yeah. And then if we're using...
And, and again, because the email marketing platforms have kinda woken up and made more data available, we can even support platforms now. I mean, ClickFunnels came in, I think was it- end, end of last year, was it? Yeah.
They, they gave us the support. Yeah. Um, you know-
Mark Harbert: That, and that was due to me pushing, like-
Adrian Savage: There you go which I'm, which I'm really glad You did a good job, and, you know, I think a lot of people should appreciate you for that. Yeah.
Um, but yeah, so that, I mean, ConvertKit, now known as Kit, even they've released stuff. Um, and the latest one is we can even report now on Kajabi.
Mark Harbert: Yeah. Yeah.
Adrian Savage: So, you know, it's... there's, there's, there's only about two, I think, the email platforms we can't support right now for things like the Smart Score, Visibility Index- Yeah and all that good stuff. Um, I think we still can't support Kartra because they, they hide everything. Yeah.
Ontraport is still pretty bad, and Drip. Those are the only three- Yeah ... that I know of that we can't- Yeah ... oh, oh, and B- Beehiiv and, um, Flowdesk. So there's bl- Yeah ... you know, there's a few, but let's face it-
Mark Harbert: Yeah
Adrian Savage: there's a lot of smart money now on GoHighLevel. You know- Yeah ... it's not the only game in town. You know, ClickFunnel still does really well. We've got ActiveCampaign.
We've got, you know, all this. I mean, some people still use Constant Contact and things like that- Yeah ... and AWeber. I mean, you know- Yeah ... back in 2012, everyone used AWeber, right?
Mark Harbert: Oh, everybody, and their brother.
Adrian Savage: Look how the world has changed.
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: But yeah, there's very few platforms that we don't support, and Visibility Center will look at what you've been sending, and it'll say, "Right, your Visibility Index is this," so that'll tell you how much you're losing on your ad spend if you do ads or if you're doing- Yeah manual or organic SEO or whatever, or just referrals. It'll tell you how many people you're failing to reach. Yeah.
Um, Smart Score tells you how well you're managing your engagement, um, and there's a ton of other stuff in there. Um, one of the things that Visibility Center does for free, and will always do for free, is DMARC reporting. Yeah. That's something that is worth looking at because I think, you know, a lot of people, they'll pay $10 a month to get their, their authentication monitored.
We're doing that for free because we wanna help people, um, and we know that authentication is gonna get tightened up at some point. At some point- Yeah Google, Microsoft, Yahoo are gonna say, "You can't have a DMARC policy where the policy is none. We're gonna have a, have a quarantine policy in place."
Mark Harbert: Yeah.
Adrian Savage: And if you're not monitoring what your authentication is doing-
Mark Harbert: Yeah ...
Adrian Savage: you might not realize if your emails suddenly start failing. Yeah. So that's, that's why we're doing that.
So Visibility Center has got a ton of things. Um, you know, there i- there is a kind of more advanced paid-for version that will help you manage your segmentation, give you advanced reporting, things like that. Yeah.
But the, but the basic important stuff, anyone can go to visibilitycenter.com and just- Yeah register for that, and it will tell you what your authentication looks like, what your Smart Score is, what your Visibility Index is. And if you look at no other metrics, that's enough- Yeah ... to tell you how safe and how healthy your email sending is.
Mark Harbert: Yeah. Well, guys, absolutely go over to visibilitycenter.com, right?
Adrian Savage: Yep.
Mark Harbert: Visibilitycenter.com. And head over there and check it out, um, and get in there. Um, Adrian, thank you, man.
This has been awesome, and, uh, this is definitely one of those topics that, um, I know I started really diving into several years ago just because I knew how things were changing. And, um, you know, remember the old days when you could send a bulk email with a Gmail account?
Adrian Savage: Oh, yeah. Yeah, exactly. You can't do that anymore.
But that, but, but I've loved it. It's been a pleasure, so- Yeah ... thank, thank you for inviting me. I hope there's some nuggets in there for everybody.
Mark Harbert: Yeah. Sounds great, guys. Make sure you, uh, share this.
If you know somebody that'll benefit, make sure you share it. Thanks for coming out to the podcast. We appreciate you.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Bootstrapped Secrets
Russell Brunson
Wired To Crush It With Tanya Aliza
Tanya Aliza
Home Business Profits with Ray Higdon
Sales Coach and Sales Trainer Ray Higdon